Board Thread:Castlevania Wiki General Discussion/@comment-3236835-20150113115945

Hi everyone.

I'm sorry to start a thread to discuss this topic but I think it was interesting enough to ask everyone for their opinion (I didn't know that editing the Magic Book page was going to open a can of worms XD).

The current layout of the Magic Book (disambiguation) page is as follows:


 * Magic Book could refer to:
 * a recurring enemy: the Magic Book
 * Weapons and Items
 * from Castlevania: Portrait of Ruin: the Tome of Arms
 * from Castlevania: Bloodlines: Spell Books (Bloodlines)
 * from Castlevania: Harmony of Dissonance: Spell Books (Harmony of Dissonance)
 * Sub-Weapons
 * Sypha Belnades' Magic Books
 * the Bible

However, I think it needs a little bit more refining. The Portrait of Ruin bullet lacks all other of Charlotte's magic books: Encyclopedia, Blank Book, Tristan&Isolde, Don Quixote and Book of Death; so I think another bulleted list should go there.

My other proposition is that these two pages: Spell Books (Bloodlines) and Spell Books (Harmony of Dissonance), should be merged into a single page and have their own sections. Speaking of which, I think the Spell Books (Bloodlines) page should be renamed to Spell Book (Bloodlines) anyway (in singular, as there's only one type of that item in the game) or maybe even simply as Spell Book (which currently is redirecting to the Magic Book page).

My proposition is something like this:


 * Magic Book could refer to:
 * Enemies
 * Magic Book
 * Weapons and Items
 * from Castlevania: Portrait of Ruin:
 * Encyclopedia
 * Blank Book
 * Tristan&Isolde
 * Don Quixote
 * Book of Death
 * Tome of Arms
 * from Castlevania: Bloodlines: Spell Book
 * from Castlevania: Harmony of Dissonance: Spell Book
 * Sub-Weapons
 * from Castlevania III: Dracula's Curse
 * Magic Books - Sypha Belnades' sub-weapons.
 * the Bible

...or something like that (I've never made a disambiguation page, so I'm not sure what's the proper format).

Please note that most of Charlotte's books pages still need to be created (they are currently redirecting to the Magic Book page too).

Please, let me know your opinion and tell me the pros and cons of both versions.

Bye. 