Talk:Rare Ring

Ring of Arcana

Any information if they do stack? I personally found different POVs in the net, nothing proving the one or anothers POV. -- anonmymous user

That's a good question, unfortunately I don't know the answer.--Reinhart77 20:55, October 1, 2011 (UTC)

It is known to stack in SotN and HD, don't know about any of the others. -- Chisa-chan, 06:44, April 26, 2014 (UTC)

Rare Ring vs. Thief Ring
It seems this page was originally named Rare Ring. At one point it was changed to Thief Ring because that's the name used in most recent titles. However, "Rare Ring" seems to be the most predominant name through the series.

Rare Ring
 * SotN (Japan)
 * HoD
 * AoS
 * DoS
 * CoD
 * DXC (not sure about this one)

Thief Ring
 * PoR
 * OoE
 * HoDspr

 _ ۩ _ LaVey _ ۩ _  " Death in the dream world will set your soul wandering for eternity. " 14:29, December 12, 2014 (UTC)

There is no change to the item name in DXC. In Japan, since all the names are "Rare Ring", I have sense of incongruity in a thief ring. It seems that the newest name is fundamentally used although I do not know the rule of this wiki. Do we need to make the rule about a page title?--Kiyuhito (talk) 00:55, November 21, 2014 (UTC)


 * Maybe we do. Maybe it could be something like:
 * First, using the original name when the item (or spell, room, etc.) was first introduced to the series.
 * If the item in question changed name throughout the series, and that name became predominant, then use that one.
 * If the item changed name in the most recent titles, but it didn't got to outweigh the old name, then keep the old one.


 * Still, this is just an idea which came up to my mind while drinking a cup of hot coffee, but I guess I'm the least one around here to propose a decision like this. I remember there was talk about coming up with a "manual of style", but I never knew what happened with that.


 *  _ ۩ _ LaVey _ ۩ _  " Death in the dream world will set your soul wandering for eternity. " 01:57, November 21, 2014 (UTC)


 * Well, it is necessary to discuss this topic in the forum.--Kiyuhito (talk) 02:59, November 21, 2014 (UTC)